Schlage Encode vs Encode Plus: Which Should You Buy

Schlage Encode vs Encode Plus: Which Should You Buy

Schlage makes two Wi-Fi-enabled smart locks that look nearly identical on store shelves — the Schlage Encode and the Schlage Encode Plus. The price gap is real, and so are the differences. This comparison breaks down exactly what you get with each model so you can make a confident purchase.

Core Differences at a Glance

The headline difference is Apple Home Key support. The Encode Plus carries an NFC chip that lets you tap your iPhone or Apple Watch directly on the lock face to unlock instantly — no app launch required. If you live in an Apple household with HomeKit devices, this single feature justifies the price premium.

Who Should Buy the Schlage Encode (Standard)

The standard Encode is one of the most reliable Wi-Fi deadbolts available. It connects directly to your router without any hub or bridge, supports the Schlage Home app, and integrates with:

• Amazon Alexa for voice control
• Google Assistant
• Ring devices (via Alexa routines)
• SmartThings (limited)

Key Strengths of the Standard Encode

1. **Built-in alarm** — the Encode includes a built-in intrusion detection alarm that triggers on forced entry attempts. This is a standout feature at this price point.
2. **Up to 100 access codes** — program codes for family members, house cleaners, dog walkers, or contractors with custom schedules.
3. **Auto-lock** — configure auto-lock from 15 seconds to 4 minutes after closing.
4. **Grade 1 ANSI/BHMA security rating** — the highest residential security rating available.

If you use Android phones, use Alexa as your primary smart home voice assistant, or don't need HomeKit, the standard Encode delivers excellent value.

Who Should Buy the Schlage Encode Plus

The Encode Plus adds Apple Home Key, full HomeKit support, and Matter compatibility. Matter is the new universal smart home protocol, meaning future platforms will support it natively.

Why Apple Home Key Matters

Apple Home Key works via NFC — your phone doesn't need to be unlocked, and you don't need to open any app. You simply tap and the door opens in under a second. It's the fastest unlock experience available on any consumer smart lock currently sold.

• Works with iPhone XS and later (iOS 15+)
• Works with Apple Watch Series 4 and later
• Stored in Wallet app with Express Mode
• Functions offline — no internet connection required for tap-to-unlock

Numbered Steps to Decide

1. Do you own an iPhone and use Apple Home or HomeKit devices? → **Buy the Encode Plus**
2. Is your household Android-first with Alexa or Google Home? → **Buy the standard Encode**
3. Are you planning a Matter smart home ecosystem? → **Buy the Encode Plus** for future compatibility
4. Budget is the primary concern? → **Save $50 with the standard Encode** — it's still Grade 1 rated

Installation Considerations

Both locks install in the same bolt hole pattern as most standard deadbolts and require no wiring. The process takes 20–30 minutes with a Phillips screwdriver. Both require a 2.4GHz Wi-Fi network — they do not support 5GHz bands.

Battery life is comparable between models: expect 6–9 months under normal use with four AA alkaline batteries. Both include a low-battery indicator in the app and on the keypad.

Final Recommendation

For most homeowners, the choice comes down to ecosystem. The Schlage Encode Plus is the smarter long-term investment if you're even slightly Apple-oriented — HomeKit, Apple Home Key, and Matter compatibility future-proof it significantly. The standard Encode remains an excellent lock for Android and Alexa households at a meaningful discount.

Both locks carry Schlage's Grade 1 ANSI/BHMA rating, which means they've been tested for over 250,000 cycles and meet the highest residential security standard. Either choice is a significant upgrade over a standard keyed deadbolt.